When a police officer shows up at the front gate of a Yale secret society after receiving a noise complaint about “someone screaming,” the alumni brothers gathered there for a reunion allow her to enter their rarefied space to investigate. But someone knows more than they’re letting on – specifically about the dead body in the back room. And as the officer conducts her investigation, we’ll learn that the question of who killed Brett might not be as simple as it seems. After all, Brett was a f*ck.